Average returns are one of retirement’s most expensive lies.
A portfolio can earn a respectable long-term average and still run out of usable income years too early. That is how average returns mislead retirees: they make a retirement plan look stable on paper while hiding the timing of losses, withdrawals, taxes, and rising costs.
The fear is not a bad year in the market. The fear is finding out at age 78 that the plan was fragile from the start. The fix is to stop judging retirement by one average return and test income year by year.
How Average Returns Mislead Retirees
An average return is a backward-looking statistic. It tells you what happened across a period. It does not tell you whether your account had enough money in the right years to support the withdrawals you needed.
That distinction matters before retirement. While you are working and adding money, a market decline can be unpleasant but manageable. You still have a paycheck. You may even buy more shares when prices are lower.
Retirement reverses that equation. You are taking money out while the market moves up and down. A decline early in retirement forces you to sell more shares to create the same income. Those shares are no longer there when the market recovers.
A plan built on “we expect 6%” can fail even if the portfolio eventually averages 6%. Markets do not deliver returns in a neat, annual paycheck. They deliver them in an order. Retirement income depends heavily on that order.
The Math Behind the Problem
Averages are not your actual experience
Suppose an investment falls 10% one year and rises 20% the next. The average annual return appears to be 5%.
But $100,000 does not become $110,000 after those two years. It falls to $90,000, then rises 20% to $108,000. The actual two-year gain is 8%, which is less than a 5% annual result compounded over two years.
That gap gets larger when returns swing more sharply. It gets more serious when you are withdrawing income along the way.
Retirees do not spend averages. They spend dollars. They pay property taxes, health insurance premiums, travel costs, and grocery bills with dollars. A retirement plan must show whether the dollars are available after a market decline, not simply whether a long-term average looks attractive.
The first years carry more weight
Consider an illustrative retiree with $1 million who needs $50,000 at the beginning of each year.
If the market drops 15% in year one and rises 20% in year two, the account falls to $807,500 after the first withdrawal and loss. After the second withdrawal and gain, it reaches $909,000.
Reverse those same two returns. The account rises to $1.14 million after the first withdrawal and gain. After the second withdrawal and loss, it ends at $926,500.
Same returns. Same average. Same withdrawals. Different ending balance.
That is sequence-of-returns risk. Early losses do more damage because the account is smaller after withdrawals. The recovery has less capital left to work with. A generic calculator that assumes a smooth annual return does not show that pressure clearly enough.
Inflation and Taxes Make the Gap Wider
Market timing is not the only problem with average-return planning. Retirement spending rarely stays flat.
A $120,000 annual lifestyle does not remain a $120,000 lifestyle for 25 or 30 years. Inflation raises the cost of everyday spending. Health care costs may rise faster than general inflation. A major repair, family need, or long-term care event can force additional withdrawals at the worst possible time.
Then taxes take their share.
Many high-income households assume they will automatically be in a lower tax bracket after they stop working. That assumption often fails. Large traditional retirement accounts create future required minimum distributions, known as RMDs. These are withdrawals the government requires from certain retirement accounts after a set age, whether you need the income or not.
RMDs can push taxable income higher. Capital gains, Social Security taxation, pension income, business-sale proceeds, and investment income can add to the pressure. Higher income can also affect Medicare premium costs.
The surviving spouse problem is even more direct. When one spouse dies, household income may not fall by half, but the tax filing status changes. The surviving spouse can reach higher tax brackets with less income. A plan that looked fine for two people may become less efficient for one.
Average returns ignore all of this unless someone forces the analysis to include it. A 7% gross return is not a 7% spendable return. Taxes, fees, inflation, and withdrawals determine what remains available for life.
A Retirement Forecast Should Work Year by Year
A useful retirement forecast does not start with a comforting average. It starts with the income you need and the risks that could interrupt it.
First, it should separate essential spending from discretionary spending. Housing, food, taxes, insurance, and basic health care are not optional. They need a dependable funding plan. Travel, gifts, and large purchases matter too, but they should not be confused with bills that must be paid regardless of market conditions.
Next, it should show income after taxes. That means estimating where each dollar comes from and how withdrawals affect taxable income over time. Pulling money from a taxable account, a traditional 401(k), an IRA, a Roth account, or a business interest can create very different tax outcomes.
It should also account for inflation every year, not as a footnote. A plan may fund the first five years comfortably and still develop a gap in year 18 because spending has risen while income has not kept pace.
Finally, it should test difficult market conditions, especially in the early retirement years. No one can predict the next market decline. But a sound plan can measure what happens if poor returns arrive early, if inflation stays elevated, or if a surviving spouse faces a higher tax burden.
That is not pessimism. It is the difference between a retirement estimate and a retirement decision.
The Fix Is Not Chasing a Higher Return
When a plan has an income gap, the wrong response is often to assume a better market return. That is not a strategy. It is a hope disguised as a spreadsheet input.
The better response is to identify which lever actually improves the outcome. It may be changing the timing of withdrawals, managing tax brackets before RMDs begin, adjusting spending, delaying a large purchase, or allocating part of the plan to assets designed to protect principal from market loss. The right mix depends on the household, the tax picture, and the income need.
More growth can help, but growth alone does not solve sequence risk. A portfolio built only for the highest expected return may expose essential income to market losses at exactly the wrong time. On the other hand, putting too much into low-volatility assets can reduce flexibility and long-term growth. The answer is not one product or one percentage. It is a coordinated income plan that shows the trade-offs clearly.
Business owners need an even closer look. A business may be the largest asset on the balance sheet, yet it may be hard to sell quickly, dependent on a small number of customers, or exposed to industry changes. Treating business value as guaranteed retirement income can create a dangerous blind spot.
The useful next step is not to hunt for a hotter return assumption. It is to test whether your current income plan survives the return sequence, taxes, inflation, and rising costs you may actually face.
Run the free Alignment Analyzer report. Then book a time with an advisor to review the gaps it finds before they become permanent.
Leave a Reply